Eeee I recorded my first song in Logic Pro, with me playing both guitar and drums! 😁 Granted it's less than a minute long and is pretty repetitive, but whatever. Yay!
Big thanks to @futzle for pointing out Logic's "quantize" functionality that will automatically move your slightly-out-of-time notes to be back in time, very helpful for getting a good drum track. The drums were was just recorded straight into Logic then quantized, rather than playing back again with any of the built-in Roland drum controller kits that the drum kit comes with (I haven't even looked into how that's done yet), and the guitar was recoded with one of Positive Grid's "BIAS Pedal" effects.
@futzle Actually I have a question about that, if I might! Just to make sure I'm understanding this right...
It seems like I'd need to have a USB recording interface that the V-Drums plug _back_ into and I'd be recording in Logic just as a standard audio track, but it'd be playing the notes I recorded originally as MIDI, right?
Good lord, I just spent the last hour and a half figuring out how to get the drums I'd recorded as MIDI in Logic Pro recorded again as just regular audio using the drum effects that the controller itself has in it (as opposed to using the drum effects that come with Logic Pro). That is not a simple piece of software.
Got there in the end though, and wrote copious notes for future me so I remember for next time. 😛 (It involves sending the output of the MIDI track to a Bus, and then having the input of that audio track set to that same Bus, then pressing Record and it'll play back the MIDI track through the drums and record it.)
@virtualwolf It depends. What’s your current setup? Where does the audio travel once it leaves your drum kit?
@futzle Ah actually, nevermind! I just found out that the drum kit supports both sending and receiving MIDI and USB audio, you just need a driver for the latter, which I hadn't installed: https://rolandus.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/360045194431-TD-17-What-the-USB-allows-me-to-do-with-the-TD-17-
(Also, colour me surprised that they've got an Apple Silicon-native version of it.)
This page was helpful for getting my head around it too: https://www.midi.org/midi-articles/how-to-record-midi-instruments
@virtualwolf Yeah, that’s the ideal setup if your equipment supports it, I was leading up to asking if it worked on your drum kit.
Most of the time I plug it into my PC using midi-over-usb, where the midi can be used to trigger sounds from EZ Drummer software, which I reckon sounds good.
Sometimes I record into a Tascam Portastudio instead, and for that I just run the analogue line out from the TD-11K into the Tascam.
I think the sounds right out of the Roland head are pretty good on their own, especially if you tweak a custom kit preset to your liking.
Using the line out doesn't allow me to do as much with the track in post, but for me that can be a blessing.
@virtualwolf Logic Pro is renowned for its complexity. I have to relearn Cubase every time I go near it, so please believe when I say that the grass is no greener elsewhere.
Welcome to thundertoot! A Mastodon Instance for 'straya